Hi everyone,
I have such a great interview for you today - and it’s two for the price of one! (Actually, it’s all free for you lovely subscribers…)
Today I spoke to two superstar literary agents, Nelle Andrew of Rachel Mills Literary (RML) and Sue Armstrong of C&W, part of Curtis Brown (please click on their names to read more about them and their amazing authors). They are both leading UK literary agents agents at the top of their game, with multiple bestselling, award-winning authors on their lists, and they are both truly wonderful, kind people to boot. Below, they share their wisdom, and I hope you enjoy reading…
1. Please can you tell us about your roles as literary agents? Where do you work and what do you represent?
NA: I see my role as manager; editor; negotiator; therapist (at times) and strategist. We are creating and guarding opportunities for long term careers in this field, and providing all the support we can to ensure this. It is all- encompassing and a much more 360 overview of the industry as a whole because you are there from inception to execution and beyond. I work at RML which started 6x years ago, with two former colleagues I used to work with at another agency. It is everything I could have hoped for from an agency and has allowed me to be the best agent I can be. In terms of representation – I only represent the kind of books I read. Sometimes that means walking away from books I know could be successful, but since I am not their readership I step back. The flip side is that if I fall in love with a new genre, I get to expand my list accordingly.
SA: I totally agree with Nelle. Agenting is many roles in one, which is what makes it so rewarding. We scout for talent, we help develop and shape projects, we sell and negotiate the best deal, we advise, guide and strategise for not only the first book but for books two, three, four… and beyond. We look at as wide a range of income opportunities for our authors as possible – US deals translation rights, TV and film adaptations, screenwriting opportunities, etc. Our role is creative and practical, but we’re also there as an emotional support. Being published is a rollercoaster and we’re there to help writers through the highs and lows.
I work at C&W Agency, where I’ve been for twenty years. We’re now part of the Curtis Brown Group and our sister agency is UTA in the US. I almost exclusively represent fiction, with the odd non-fiction project/memoir. My list is very broad – literary, historical, SFF, crime, gothic, contemporary, commercial… and this reflects how I read. Strong voice and character are the most important elements of a story for me so if I love those, I don’t mind what the genre is or where the story takes me.
2. What is the best part about being a literary agent?
NA: Being part of an overall life rather than just the life of a book. I do not have to make decisions by committee – if I see something I love and believe in, I get to devote myself to it entirely without any interference. It is freeing, but it is also very risky because you live and die by your taste – but as an only child, I am naturally suited for this kind of independence. Also just being part of the extraordinary life change for someone – to be an instrumental part in ushering this new life full of writing and authorship and implementing their dream from thought to reality – it is a complete privilege.
SA: I still find the discovery moment so exciting. It only happens a few times a year, if you’re lucky, but the moment you open a submission and realise that you’re reading the work of a major new talent is thrilling. Another wonderful part of agenting is then getting to work with that new writer not just on their debut but over many years and on many books. There is, of course, also huge joy in being able to tell someone that they are going to be published for the first time. It can be life-changing and to play a role in that is, as Nelle says, a real privilege.
3. And the most challenging?
NA: They say you’re only as happy as your unhappiest child and I think they were secretly thinking of agents alongside this. When things are not going well for someone on your list, I find it heartbreaking, because the world has yet to catch up with what I know to be true – that they are brilliant. Sometimes it takes time, but it requires huge forms of faith and strategy and that can be exhausting. Also – to be honest – what I find most challenging right now, are publishers who are not able to think beyond initial success. The market is very difficult and those who are persistent and continuous at aiming for things, instead of balking at the first disappointment, have the kind of will I want for my author. But they are not as ubiquitous as they should be and frankly, that really pisses me off.
SA: It’s always difficult when you have to share bad news with an author. That never gets any easier, but I find lack of communication from a publisher the most challenging thing. If things aren’t going as well for a book as we’d all hoped, the way to constructively address that is to work together, assessing all the data, re-strategising as a team and pivoting where necessary. There’s no way to do this without openness and good communication between agent and publisher. I also feel there’s too much focus on sales track (how the author’s previous books have sold). Poor sales track often has little to do with how strong the book is and many of the biggest, bestselling authors we know today sold few copies of their earlier books, so it doesn’t follow that low sales mean there isn’t a readership. I’d love each book to be judged on its own merit, but I appreciate publishers have to use data as part of their decision making.
4. Are there any particular professional highlights you want to share with us?
NA: Sara Collins winning the Costa for her debut novel; having THE LIST OF SUSPICIOUS THINGS by Jennie Godfrey reach no 1 in paperback as a debut this year; having Jing-Jing Lee longlisted for the Women’s Fiction Prize; when Bryony Gordon’s MAD GIRL was no 1 in a time when so many publishers said her kind of non-fiction would never succeed. She was a true pioneer at her time. Every author who was ever been turned down or dismissed then going on to be published and find success. Being the first POC to win Agent of the Year at the Nibbies and honestly, becoming an honorary fellow of the RSL. Signing my name on the scroll using George Eliot’s pen will be one of the most seminal moments of my whole life, let alone my career.
SA: What amazing highlights, Nelle! An early and rather glam highlight for me was going to the film premier of M.L. Stedman’s debut, THE LIGHT BETWEEN OCEANS, at the Venice Film Festival, then having dinner afterwards with the cast, including *ahem* Michael Fassbender and Alicia Vikander. It’s hard to top that. A big prize listing is always a treat so I’ll include Joanna Cannon’s THREE THINGS ABOUT ELSIE and Miranda Cowley Heller’s THE PAPER PALACE being longlisted for the Women’s Prize for Fiction. Seeing Jo Callaghan’s debut IN THE BLINK OF AN EYE not only hit the Sunday Times bestseller list but go on to win multiple prizes was a particular highlight as I’d not managed to sell Jo’s first novel (I’m sure she won’t mind me saying this) so to see her keep going and then write a prize-winning bestseller was amazing. Also Kim Sherwood being chosen by the Ian Fleming Estate to write a series of DOUBLE O books is a highlight because Kim is a James Bond obsessive and this was literally a childhood dream come true for her.
How many submissions do you think you receive per month?
NA: So many – enough to comfortably be submerged but enough that I drown.
SA: 400-500. It’s always been a huge number, but while it can feel overwhelming, I have a soft spot for the ‘slush pile’ as it’s known. About half of my list came from unsolicited submissions and it’s so exciting when you find a gem there.
6. How do you stay on top of submissions, and how long is your reply process?
NA: I work from home on Fridays, but also I know within a page and the pitch whether something will be for me. I make decisions very quickly because I am over 40x; have been doing this for years and I know what I respond to and what I don’t. I don’t have to talk myself into anything. It’s immediate.
SA: I used to reply to every submission, but I just can’t manage it now. Partly because I would so frequently get emails back asking for editorial feedback or advice on what to do next, and partly because my list and role is bigger; it became unmanageable. Now if someone submits to my submissions email, they get a note saying that if they’ve not heard from me within six weeks, unfortunately that means the book isn’t for me. Not responding to every submission is a huge source of guilt for me. If down the line I can find a way to go back to responding to everyone, I will try to do so. I do tend to know very quickly if something is for me.
What is the number one reason you will turn a book down?
NA: Simply put, if I don’t care. If I don’t care what happens to these people and I can live happily without finding out. This is true of all forms for me – whether it is a submission or a published novel or a movie or TV show. If I don’t care, there’s no point.
SA: Similar to Nelle really. If I’m not very quickly invested in the characters and desperate to know what becomes of them, then it’s not for me.
What makes you sit up and take notice, and call in a full manuscript?
NA: Confidence of voice. If you know from the first line that this is an author who KNOWS their voice; who is in love with their story and you are immediately submerged into it. It’s like dipping your face into a pool of water – the current is already moving and you’re inserting yourself into it at just that moment. It is difficult to describe, but the voice is key. You know it when someone has it and when someone does not. Also engaging characters and an actual story – not a long anecdote wrung out too far.
SA: A distinct voice, great characters, and instant immersion in the story. By voice, I mean if I picked the book up randomly and opened a page, I would know immediately from the writing who the author was. That’s voice. In the same way you can tell which friend has texted you, not from the name at the top, but by the way they write their message to you. It’s unique and authentic to them. By instant immersion in the story, I mean what Nelle said re. dipping your face into a pool of moving water. You join the story when it’s already in motion. You very quickly know who your main character is and what question/situation/dilemma is going to propel them through the narrative.
9. How much editorial work do you do with writers before you send the books out on submission?
NA: Ha! My authors have called it Nelle’s Boot Camp, so a lot I guess. I am rigorous, and I do warn someone not to sign with me if they don’t want to be put through their paces. I won’t send out anything I am not 100% happy with and if that means I am not for you – then I am not for you. I don’t want someone cos-playing writing. The writing and editing should be the part they enjoy the most.
SA: Like Nelle, I’m very much an editorial literary agent as I too have a strong focus on editing with my authors. Publishers receive a vast number of submissions from agents, so editors are looking for reasons not to take something forward, and one of those reasons might be the novel is not polished enough or needs too much editorial work. I want to pre-empt and remove any obstacles I can before submission, so ensuring the manuscript is as strong as it possibly can be is vital. It can be a lot of work but editorial is always in conversation with the author, working out together how to make the manuscript as brilliant it can be whilst also staying true to their vision for the book.
10. How do you decide which editors to send a book to?
NA: What they’ve published before; their reputation; HOW they have published things and what authors say about them; whether I admire their list as a reader and if their reputation means we have a compatible work ethic.
SA: We’re seeing editors for lunch and coffee all the time so it’s finding out what they are hungry for, knowing what they’ve published and published well. Their reputation, as Nelle says, is important. I also consider the imprint they work for as a whole – has there been a lot of movement there recently (i.e. have people left/is there a high turnover) and whether they stay committed to authors even if the first book doesn’t sell well.
11. How do you decide whether to go to auction or encourage an author to accept an offer?
NA: Oh god – that’s a tough one. Sometimes the sheer force of will from the publisher has made me walk away from an auction because I don’t believe another person will have the same level of commitment to this author as they do. But often it’s because I cannot say hand over heart that this package is the best for the author. If I am not wholly certain, then I let it play out at auction. It is always about finding the best home for my author – not about me and my ego.
SA: This is hard to answer because every situation is unique with lots of factors at play. It’s dependent on who is offering, the level, the imprint, what sort of author is involved (some don’t like making decisions under pressure), who else is potentially involved/offering… Plus many other considerations. It is the author’s decision, but we are there to advise and guide so that they come to the right decision for them.
12. Can authors change agents partway through their careers? Can you talk a bit about this?
NA: Yeah they do. It sucks ass when it happens. I have been dumped and it’s always unpleasant, even if people do it respectfully. You sit there going through everything, wondering what you did wrong and why. It’s like being dumped in a relationship, because it IS a relationship and it is heartbreaking. I have been dumped because they didn’t agree with my edits; because they wanted a bigger more corporate agency; because we just didn’t agree on what direction they should take for their career. Painful. But – even though it hurts, I will say this: I have always found that afterwards something has opened up for me in a new way than before. I have ended up with space, which means I look for other opportunities and dedicate my energies in new ways. I look at those incidences now and am grateful for them – because in saying goodbye, something else came in that expanded me further and made me a better agent. I don’t know if it was right for them, but it doesn’t matter – our paths are no longer aligned. Being in this business, these things happen but you have to dust yourself off and get back up and not be defined by what didn’t work out, but rather what you are going to do with that new space.
SA: This does happen, and it happens in both directions – sometimes you part with one of your authors and it can be hard (but it can also feel right for both author and agent) and sometimes you can start working with a wonderful author who used to be represented by someone else. It’s a partnership so if one party isn’t 100% invested in the other or they have a different vision, then it just doesn’t work. Fortunately it doesn’t happen often, but if I part ways with an author, or they part ways with me, I just look at the rest of my list and think how lucky I am to represent so many amazing writers. And then I’m OK.
13. Your role is often to advocate on behalf of the author. What is your relationship like with the publishers?
NA: I start from a space of respect and teamwork. We are all aiming for the same thing which is success. I know when a team is doing everything they can and when things are beyond their control and you have to be fair. Fairness for me is key. I want everyone involved in this endeavour to be treated with respect and fairness and to see their contributions valued. However, if I feel someone is behaving badly – being disrespectful; lying; unprofessional then I will not hesitate to bring that to the fore. Life is too short and our jobs are too hard to be treated like shit. But that goes both ways for me – I have fired two authors in my career because their behaviour was below the threshold of care I would have expected them to show their teams. However, I will never work with someone I feel is undervaluing my author professionally, and I will move authors from publishers if this is the case. For authors this is everything, not just another book on a conveyor belt of books. I am fortunate to work with some great publishers and authors who operate on the same value system I have, so this rarely becomes a problem. But if it does become a problem, I will face it, even if I wish it didn’t have to be that way.
SA: Our role is always to advocate on behalf of the author but as Nelle says, we’re all working towards the same goal of making a book and author a success so it’s important to have a good relationship with publishers. It’s a team effort, which should be collaborative and constructive, with good communication. If things go wrong somewhere in the process, then it must be addressed but that can be done respectfully, looking for solutions together going forwards.
14. What advice would you give to writers?
NA: Safeguard your mental health – this isn’t a hobby, and it can really wear and tear at you. Persistence and perseverance is key. If you don’t feel successful without being published, you won’t feel it after being published – do not set your self-worth by the store of how a business commodifies you. However – do not give up. To me there is nothing better in the world than a book. To be an author is serious and takes serious work, but it’s also a deep privilege and honour. You get to live in the hearts and minds of people you’ll never meet, people who have yet to be born and influence their emotions far beyond the confines of the page. It is an extraordinary fate.
SA: I would say if you want to be professional writer, rather than a hobbyist, i.e. you want to be paid for your writing, then you need to think about who your reader is, what do they want in a novel, which other author’s readers would you like to be reading your novel. How are you going to convince them to part with their cash to buy your book over all the other books displayed in bookshops? Pitch your book out loud to yourself and to others. Does it sound unique and compelling? If you were an agent/publisher/bookseller who was hearing maybe 50 pitches in an hour, would your pitch stand out? It doesn’t have to be high-concept (though that helps) but you do need to have an intriguing premise. For someone to think, ‘I’ve not heard that before.’ There are lots of different elements that can make your story stand out: setting, concept, moral dilemma, perspective, opening gambit, character’s occupation… I would also say, don’t be disheartened if you get agent rejections, even lots of them. It’s a rite of passage and it doesn’t mean your writing isn’t good, it’s just you’ve not found your match yet. If you keep finding you’re getting nowhere, join a writing community where you can share and feedback on each other’s work. It can be a lonely profession, so build a few people around you.
Thank you so much to Sue Armstrong and Nelle Andrew for sharing such brilliant insights with The Honest Editor, and with all of you.
As ever, please do post any questions or comments below, DM me, and share this with your networks if you think it will help others! And if you want to read more about getting an agent, I wrote about it here, and if you would like advice on how to find your hook, there’s some here.
Phoebe x



I love this Substack and read every post so it is amazing to see my agent mention me in one (thank you Sue!). There is such great advice here from Nelle and Sue for anyone going on submission or just trying to keep going. It took me 13 years and 5 unpublished books (2 of which Sue and I submitted to publishers with no luck) before my crime debut In the Blink of an Eye was finally published and thanks to the team was a relative success. So good luck but as Nelle says, do look after your mental health as it can be tough xxx
Really engaging and informative, thank you Phoebe, Nelle and Sue. (Found this via Jennie Godfrey linking to it on Notes!)